Asking Questions Isn’t the Problem

TL;DR: Trustees make decisions that affect how your tax dollars are spent. To do that responsibly, we need to understand the information we're given, even when that means asking uncomfortable questions. Poor decisions can be expensive. If I'm asked to consider raising taxes, I want to be able to explain exactly why it's necessary and be confident we've explored every reasonable alternative first.
Wait, Someone Thinks We Aren't Supposed to Ask Questions?
When government and money appear in the same sentence, it's understandable that people start thinking about overspending, fraud, corruption, or higher taxes. We've all heard enough stories about government getting something wrong to know those concerns aren't imaginary. But how do we help prevent those problems? We ask questions. Sometimes those questions uncover a problem, sometimes they reveal an opportunity to improve something, and sometimes the answer is perfectly reasonable and everyone moves on with a better understanding.
Which brings me to something I find genuinely puzzling about the current conversation in Lakewood. Asking questions about Village finances has been characterized as a problem. Examining financial reports, checking calculations, or seeking clarification has been described as interference, micromanagement, or an unnecessary burden on Village operations. I understand that questions take time to answer and that the way they're asked matters, but I struggle with the suggestion that a trustee trying to understand information they're expected to act upon is somehow doing something they shouldn't.
Because understanding that information isn't just part of the job. It's the basis of the job.
So, What Really Is the Job?
Lakewood operates under the President-Trustee form of government, with an elected Village President and six trustees. Together, we make policy and legislative decisions for the community. Lakewood's Municipal Code, Sections 2.01 and 2.03, establishes the Board's role and refers to the duties and powers provided under Illinois law. Under 65 ILCS 5/3.1-45-5, trustees have authority to pass ordinances, resolutions, and motions. And under 65 ILCS 5/3.1-35-40, the municipal treasurer's books and accounts are expressly subject to inspection by members of the corporate authorities, which includes trustees.
In other words, examining financial information isn't some unusual activity trustees have invented. Illinois law specifically recognizes the authority of elected municipal officials to inspect financial records. The law doesn't require trustees to be accountants, engineers, or experts in everything that comes before the Board. That would make for a rather interesting candidate recruitment process. But it does give us responsibilities that require judgment.
If I'm asked to approve an expenditure, I should understand what we're buying, why we need it, and how we're paying for it. If I'm asked to approve a budget, I should understand the assumptions behind the numbers. My responsibility doesn't end when I receive those reports. That's where it begins. That doesn't mean I'll always agree with a recommendation. It means I need to understand what I'm agreeing to.
About Those Spreadsheets
Most months, trustees receive Village financial reports as PDFs. They're fine for reading, but less useful when you want to compare figures, check calculations, or understand how numbers relate to one another. Sometimes I put those numbers into a spreadsheet to help me understand them. A spreadsheet is just a calculator with a really good memory.
That isn't creating a second set of Village books or replacing the Village's accounting system. It's using a tool to examine information we've already received. No, I'm not a CPA, and I've never claimed to be one. I have an MBA with a focus on data analysis and have spent much of my career working with data to make decisions. But my qualifications aren't really the point. You shouldn't need to be a CPA to ask questions about public money, and you certainly shouldn't need to be one to serve as a trustee.
But Doesn't Answering Questions Take Staff Time?
Of course it does, and staff time is a resource we should respect. But there's a difference between asking someone to create an entirely new analysis and asking for clarification or existing supporting documentation for a report they've already prepared. If a financial statement contains a number I don't understand, asking where it came from or what it represents is a reasonable part of reviewing that statement. Sometimes the explanation is straightforward. Sometimes municipal accounting is complicated enough that it requires additional research. Either way, we're trying to understand information we're being asked to rely upon.
I also believe those questions should go through the appropriate administrative channels, and Village employees shouldn't be caught in political disagreements. But time spent helping elected officials understand the information behind their decisions isn't inherently wasted time. If a report is important enough to inform a decision involving public money, understanding it is important, too.
And yes, I've also asked for changes in how information is presented, with the goal of making the numbers easier to understand and reducing the need for follow-up questions. Those requests have gone to the Board as a whole, where we've discussed what's reasonable given the systems our staff use. Some of my suggestions have been accepted, others rejected, and I'm fine with both outcomes. The important thing is that we've had those conversations, and I believe the changes we've made have improved our reporting.
Accountability Isn't an Attack
Questioning information isn't the same as questioning the integrity of the person who provided it. If I ask why an expense is higher than budgeted, I'm not automatically accusing someone of wasting money. If I ask why two reports show different figures, I'm not suggesting someone is hiding something. And if I ask a follow-up question, it doesn't mean I'm refusing to accept an answer. It often means I still don't understand.
I recognize that conversations can become heated. I've seen trustees become frustrated (myself included), and frustration doesn't excuse disrespect. I ran for office promising to help change the tone of the conversation in Lakewood, and I still believe we should be able to disagree without making things personal. That standard applies to everyone. Our Village employees deserve respect, support, and leadership that distinguishes legitimate oversight from personal criticism. When something needs correcting, the goal should be to understand what happened and improve the process, not assign blame before understanding the facts. In my professional experience, spending time assigning blame usually takes time away from understanding what went wrong and improving the process.
But elected officials are accountable, too. We're responsible for the decisions we make, including those made without asking questions we should have asked. And I keep coming back to this: Why would we want the people making decisions about public money to understand less about the information behind those decisions?
The Real Cost of Not Understanding
Here's where this matters to you. Every budget we approve, contract we authorize, and financial commitment we make has consequences. Some are immediate. Others won't become apparent for years. When trustees don't understand the information they're relying on, they risk making poor decisions that could mean unnecessary spending, deferred maintenance, reduced services, or obligations that limit our choices in the future. Eventually, those consequences can put pressure on taxes and fees.
Lakewood faces important decisions involving RedTail, fire protection, infrastructure, and the cost of maintaining Village services. I don't believe raising taxes is the answer to every financial challenge, but I also don't believe keeping taxes low today automatically means we're making responsible decisions for tomorrow. Sometimes additional revenue may be necessary. Sometimes we need to reconsider how we operate or what we can afford. Either way, we should understand our options before making those decisions.
Because if I'm asked to consider raising taxes, I want to be able to look you in the eye and explain why. I want to know what the money is needed for, what alternatives we considered, and what we've done to control costs. I want to be confident we've done everything reasonably possible to avoid asking residents to pay more unnecessarily. And I can't do that if I'm expected to accept financial information without understanding it.
So What Do We Do About It?
I think we start by changing how we talk about questions. Instead of treating requests for clarification as accusations, let's recognize them as part of responsible oversight. Instead of assuming a follow-up question means someone is looking for a fight, let's consider whether the original question was answered. Good oversight requires asking questions, listening to the answers, respecting expertise, and being willing to change our minds when the facts support it. And that goes for both those who are asking and those being asked.
A Lakewood resident recently shared a phrase with me that has stayed with me: Deferred Accountability. We understand deferred maintenance. Ignore a problem long enough, and it becomes more expensive to fix. Accountability can work the same way. Questions left unanswered and decisions made without sufficient understanding can create problems someone else eventually has to address. That's not the government I want for Lakewood.
You don't have to read every financial report or attend every Board meeting. That's part of why you elect representatives. But you should be able to expect us to understand the information we're using to make decisions on your behalf.
Asking questions isn't the problem. Making decisions without understanding the answers might be. And when those decisions involve your money, we all have something at stake.
Sources
Village of Lakewood Municipal Code, Chapter 2, Sections 2.01 and 2.03.
Illinois Municipal Code, 65 ILCS 5/3.1-45-5, Board of Trustees.
Illinois Municipal Code, 65 ILCS 5/3.1-35-40, Treasurer's duties and inspection of accounts.


Comments